FD vs RD vs PPF: Which Gives More After Tax? Worked Numbers for Every Tax Slab

Most people compare fixed deposits, recurring deposits and PPF by looking at the headline interest rate. That is the wrong number. What matters is what is left in your hands after tax, how long the money is locked, and how the interest is calculated. A 7% fixed deposit and a 7.1% PPF look almost the same on a bank’s rate board, but for someone in the 30% tax slab they are very different investments.

This guide compares the three on a post-tax basis with worked numbers, shows the break-even rate for each slab, and ends with a simple way to decide. All rates are illustrative. Bank deposit rates change often and PPF is reset quarterly by the government, so check current rates before acting.

The three products in one table

FeatureFixed Deposit (FD)Recurring Deposit (RD)PPF
How you investOne lump sumFixed amount every monthFlexible, ₹500 to ₹1.5 lakh a year
Tenure7 days to 10 years, your choiceUsually 6 months to 10 years15 years, extendable in 5-year blocks
Interest rateFixed at bookingFixed at bookingReset every quarter by the government
CompoundingUsually quarterlyUsually quarterlyAnnual
Tax on interestTaxable at your slab, yearlyTaxable at your slab, yearlyTax-free
LiquidityPremature exit with a small penaltyPremature exit with a small penaltyLocked, with limited loans and withdrawals
SafetyBank risk; deposit insurance up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bankSame as FDSovereign-backed

How tax works on FD and RD interest

Interest on FDs and RDs is added to your income and taxed at your slab rate. It is taxed every year as it accrues, even if the FD pays out only at maturity, so a five-year cumulative FD has tax due each year on interest you have not yet received. Banks deduct tax at source (TDS) when the interest from one bank crosses a yearly threshold. The thresholds were raised in the 2025 Union Budget to ₹50,000 for most depositors and ₹1 lakh for senior citizens, but confirm the current limits with your bank. Below the threshold there is no TDS, but the interest is still taxable and must be reported in your return.

If your total income is below the taxable limit, you can submit Form 15G (or Form 15H for senior citizens) to stop TDS being deducted. If TDS has been deducted and your actual tax is lower, you can claim a refund while filing your return. A 4% health and education cess applies on top of the tax, which is why the effective rate in the top slab is 31.2%, not 30%.

The post-tax return on a 7% FD

Take a 7% FD. Here is what each slab keeps. The effective tax rate includes the 4% cess, and surcharge for very high incomes is ignored.

Tax slabEffective tax ratePost-tax return on 7% FD
0% (no tax)0%7.00%
5%5.2%6.64%
10%10.4%6.27%
20%20.8%5.54%
30%31.2%4.82%

Against a PPF rate of 7.1%, which is tax-free, the FD wins only when your tax rate is zero and the FD rate is higher. In every taxed slab, PPF delivers more.

The break-even FD rate for each slab

A more useful question: what pre-tax FD rate would you need to match PPF at 7.1% after tax? Divide 7.1% by (1 − effective tax rate).

Tax slabFD rate needed to match PPF at 7.1%
5%about 7.49%
10%about 7.92%
20%about 8.96%
30%about 10.32%

Few banks offer 9% or 10% on regular FDs, so for people in the 20% and 30% slabs, PPF is difficult to beat among safe, fixed-income choices. This is exactly why tax-free products matter more as your income rises. The comparison also shows why a “slightly higher” FD rate rarely compensates for the tax.

Worked example: ₹5 lakh in a 5-year FD

Suppose you put ₹5 lakh in a five-year FD at 7%, compounded quarterly. The maturity value before tax is about ₹7.07 lakh, so you earn roughly ₹2.07 lakh in interest. If you are in the 30% slab, tax on that interest, at 31.2%, comes to about ₹65,000, leaving roughly ₹6.43 lakh in your hands. The real post-tax growth is about 4.8% a year, which is close to or below typical long-run inflation. In a 5% slab, you would keep about ₹6.9 lakh.

This is a simplification. Tax is actually paid each year on accrued interest, which slightly reduces your compounding base, so the true result is a little lower for taxpayers who pay the tax from the FD proceeds. The direction is clear, though.

Worked example: ₹10,000 a month in a 5-year RD

An RD suits people who prefer to save from monthly income. At 6.5% with quarterly compounding, ₹10,000 a month for five years (60 deposits, ₹6 lakh in total) matures at about ₹7.1 lakh, which means about ₹1.1 lakh of interest. At a 30% slab the tax on that is roughly ₹34,000, reducing the net gain to about ₹76,000.

The effective rate looks lower than the stated 6.5% because each instalment is invested for a shorter time than the full five years. This is the point many people miss: an RD’s headline rate applies to each deposit only for the time it stays in. Missing instalments can also attract a small penalty and may cause the bank to treat the account as irregular.

Where PPF fits, and where it does not

PPF is the strongest of the three on pure post-tax return, but it has two constraints. First, it is capped at ₹1.5 lakh a year, so it cannot absorb a large lump sum. Second, the 15-year lock-in makes it unsuitable for money you may need in a few years. We explain the rules, the 5th-of-the-month interest trick and the maturity numbers in our detailed PPF guide.

For goals within one to five years, such as a down payment, school fees or a planned trip, FDs and RDs are the practical choice because you control the tenure. For goals ten to fifteen years away, a PPF-first approach usually makes sense for the debt part of the portfolio.

Other fixed-income options worth knowing

  • Tax-saver FD: a five-year FD that qualifies for Section 80C deduction under the old tax regime, with no premature withdrawal. The interest is still taxable.
  • Senior Citizens’ Savings Scheme: a government scheme for those aged 60 and above with a higher rate, quarterly payouts and a five-year term. Interest is taxable.
  • National Savings Certificate: a five-year post office certificate with fixed rates and 80C eligibility for deposits. Interest is taxable but reinvested interest can count as eligible deduction in the first four years under current rules.
  • Debt mutual funds and bonds: taxed differently and carry market risk, so they are outside the scope of this comparison.

Rules, rates and tax treatment of each have been revised repeatedly, so verify them on official sites before investing.

A simple decision method

  1. Name the goal and the date. Less than three years away: FD or RD. More than ten years away: PPF for the safe part.
  2. Check your slab. At 20% or 30%, convert every FD rate to its post-tax figure before comparing.
  3. Fill PPF first if the lock-in suits you, up to the amount you can comfortably leave untouched.
  4. Use FDs for goals and emergency funds, laddering maturities so some money frees up every year.
  5. Use an RD to build the habit if your income is monthly and you struggle to save a lump sum.
  6. Keep growth assets for long goals. Safe products rarely beat inflation by much after tax. Read how a systematic plan works in our guide to SIP vs lumpsum.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing pre-tax FD rates with tax-free PPF rates.
  • Ignoring TDS and failing to report FD interest even when no TDS was deducted.
  • Breaking an FD early for a small need, losing the penalty and the higher rate.
  • Putting all long-term savings into fixed income and falling behind inflation.
  • Keeping more than ₹5 lakh in one bank, which is the limit of deposit insurance per depositor per bank.

To test your own amounts, rates and tenures, use the free Financial Calculators India app and read the Financial Calculators India guide. If you are also weighing loans, see how to reduce home loan EMI and total interest. The rest of our tools are on the products page.

Frequently asked questions

Is FD interest taxed when I receive it or when it accrues?

For most individuals it is taxed each year as it accrues, even in a cumulative FD that pays out only at maturity.

Is RD better than FD?

They suit different situations. An FD is for a lump sum you already have; an RD is a savings habit from monthly income. Rates are often similar.

Does PPF always beat FD?

Not always. For someone with no tax liability, a higher FD rate can win. PPF also cannot hold large amounts or provide short-term liquidity.

Can I avoid TDS on FD interest?

If your total taxable income is below the limit, submit Form 15G or 15H. Otherwise, TDS is deducted and you can claim credit or a refund in your return.

Disclaimer: This article is general education, not financial, tax or investment advice. Interest rates, TDS limits and tax rules change. Verify current figures with your bank, official notifications or a qualified adviser. Figures are illustrations using assumed rates.

Leave a Reply

Share Your Love