Learn how to comment on blog articles naturally, avoid spam, build relationships, drive referral traffic, and earn legitimate dofollow backlinks safely.
How to Comment on Blog Articles and Earn Dofollow Backlinks Without Spam: The Complete White-Hat Blog Commenting Guide
Blog commenting is one of the oldest forms of online community participation. Long before social networks became dominant, bloggers, publishers, journalists, marketers and readers built relationships through comment sections.
Unfortunately, blog commenting also became one of the most abused SEO tactics.
For years, backlink builders searched for blogs with open comment forms, inserted keyword-rich names, posted generic comments such as “Great article, thanks for sharing,” and added links to commercial websites. Automated tools eventually scaled the practice to thousands of comments.
That approach is not modern SEO.
It is spam.
Google explicitly identifies forum comments containing optimized links as an example of link spam when those links are created primarily to manipulate search rankings. Google also treats comment spam as a form of user-generated spam.
Yet this does not mean blog commenting is useless.
When done correctly, commenting can help bloggers:
- participate in professional communities;
- build relationships with publishers;
- demonstrate expertise;
- attract referral visitors;
- become recognizable within a niche;
- generate content ideas;
- create networking opportunities;
- earn mentions;
- develop collaborations;
- and occasionally earn natural followed links when a publisher independently decides that a contributor or cited resource deserves one.
The goal therefore should not be:
“How can I place as many dofollow comment backlinks as possible?”
The better question is:
“How can I become such a useful participant in relevant blog communities that links, mentions, relationships and traffic emerge naturally?”
That is the approach this guide explains.
What Is Blog Commenting?
Blog commenting is the practice of participating in discussions beneath published articles by sharing observations, questions, additional information, constructive criticism or relevant experience.
A high-quality comment extends the article.
For example, imagine an article explaining how small businesses can improve local SEO.
A poor comment might say:
“Excellent article. Very useful information. Visit my SEO company.”
A genuinely valuable comment might say:
“One additional issue small businesses should audit is whether multiple Google Business Profile categories accurately reflect their actual services. I have seen businesses focus heavily on citations while overlooking category relevance. It would be interesting to know whether you have observed similar issues in competitive local markets.”
The second comment contributes something.
It demonstrates that the commenter read the article, understands the topic and can participate intelligently in the conversation.
That difference is fundamental.
Blog commenting becomes valuable when the comment itself deserves to exist even if no backlink is available.
Use that as your first quality test.
If you would not post the comment without receiving a backlink, the motivation may already be too link-focused.
What Is a Dofollow Backlink?
“Dofollow” is informal SEO terminology.
Technically, HTML links do not need a rel="dofollow" attribute.
A normal link might simply appear as:
<a href="https://example.com/">Example</a>
When publishers want to communicate additional information about a link, they may use attributes such as:
rel="nofollow"
rel="ugc"
rel="sponsored"
Google recommends using rel="ugc" for links within user-generated content such as blog comments and forum posts. Google also says publishers may choose to remove that attribute from links posted by trusted contributors who have consistently provided high-quality contributions.
That last point is extremely important.
It suggests the healthiest route toward a followed contributor link is not trying to discover technical loopholes.
It is earning trust.
Nofollow, UGC and Dofollow Links: What Bloggers Need to Understand
A decade ago, SEO discussions often treated links as binary:
dofollow = valuable
nofollow = useless
That view is outdated.
Google announced in 2019 that nofollow, ugc and sponsored are treated as hints about how links should be understood rather than as a simplistic universal on/off switch.
This means bloggers should stop evaluating every commenting opportunity solely by whether an SEO browser extension displays “follow” or “nofollow.”
A nofollow or UGC comment link can still deliver:
referral visitors;
brand exposure;
professional relationships;
journalist discovery;
future collaboration opportunities;
customer enquiries;
newsletter subscribers;
social media connections;
and indirect opportunities for genuine editorial backlinks.
A followed link from a dead, spam-filled blog may be worth far less strategically than a UGC link from a respected industry publication whose readers actually visit your website.
Why Comment Backlinks Became Associated With Spam
Blog comment spam became attractive because commenting platforms historically made link creation easy.
A typical WordPress comment form might request:
Name
Email
Website
Comment
That website field created a clickable link behind the commenter’s name.
SEO practitioners realized they could manipulate the field.
Instead of entering:
Biswajit
someone might enter:
Best SEO Company India
The resulting anchor text became a commercial keyword.
Scaled across hundreds of blogs, this produced an obvious footprint.
Automation made it worse.
Programs could scrape websites, identify open comment forms and submit thousands of comments automatically.
Google’s current spam policies specifically include forum comments containing optimized links as an example of link spam.
Modern publishers also have far better spam filtering, moderation systems and reputation controls than early blogs did.
The era of mass comment backlink building should therefore be considered over.
The New Purpose of Blog Commenting
Modern blog commenting should be treated primarily as:
community participation + reputation building + relationship development + referral discovery
Backlinks are secondary.
This change in mindset transforms the strategy.
Instead of asking:
“Where can I insert my URL?”
ask:
“Where are the people I want to learn from, help, collaborate with or become known by?”
That question leads you toward high-quality communities rather than spam opportunities.
The Real SEO Value of Blog Commenting
The direct ranking value of blog comments is often exaggerated.
The indirect value can be substantial.
Content Discovery
A thoughtful comment can introduce your name and expertise to publishers, editors, researchers and readers.
If someone finds your contribution useful, they may visit your profile or website.
Later they might reference one of your articles.
That independent editorial citation is considerably more valuable than mechanically placing another comment backlink.
Referral Traffic
If a blog receives real readership, comments can generate visitors.
These visitors are especially valuable because they have already demonstrated interest in your subject area.
A visitor coming from a detailed SEO discussion is potentially far more relevant to an SEO consultancy than an anonymous visitor coming from an unrelated directory.
Authority Building
Regularly participating in a niche community can make your name recognizable.
Authority rarely develops from one comment.
It develops from repeated evidence of expertise.
A blogger who consistently adds useful observations beneath respected publications may eventually be invited to:
contribute an article;
join a podcast;
participate in a webinar;
provide expert commentary;
collaborate on research;
review a tool;
or share a case study.
Each opportunity can create far stronger visibility and backlink potential than the original comments.
Relationship Building
Publishers notice regular contributors.
If you repeatedly contribute without self-promotion, your name becomes familiar.
Familiarity reduces the friction of future outreach.
A cold email saying:
“I have been reading your blog for years”
carries little evidence.
An email from someone who has participated intelligently in ten discussions is different.
The relationship already exists.
Rule Number One: Never Comment Only for the Link
This rule eliminates most spam automatically.
Before posting, ask:
Would I still submit this comment if the website field were removed?
If the answer is no, reconsider the comment.
The strongest comments have independent value.
The link should simply identify who you are or provide a genuinely useful supporting resource.
How to Find Blogs Worth Commenting On
Do not search only for phrases such as:
“dofollow blogs”
“dofollow comment sites”
“high DA comment backlinks”
“instant approval blog comments”
These searches frequently lead directly to spam ecosystems.
Instead, search for influential publications within your actual niche.
For SEO professionals, that may include websites discussing:
technical SEO;
content strategy;
analytics;
WordPress;
web development;
digital PR;
AI search;
conversion optimization;
digital marketing.
For photographers, it may include photography communities.
For financial analysts, industry publications.
For developers, engineering blogs.
Relevance matters much more than building a giant list of random domains.
Google’s link guidance emphasizes providing contextual, meaningful links rather than manipulating ranking signals.
Evaluate the Blog Before Commenting
Before investing time in a publication, examine several characteristics.
A useful commenting environment usually has:
real editorial content;
active or recent publishing;
recognizable authors;
genuine reader discussions;
moderation;
relevant subject matter;
reasonable website quality;
realistic engagement;
comments that contain thoughtful discussion rather than obvious spam.
Avoid websites where the comment section looks like:
“Nice post.”
“Great information.”
“Thanks.”
“Visit casino website.”
“Best loans online.”
“Best SEO company.”
Even if such a site offers followed links, it is unlikely to be a valuable professional environment.
Domain Authority Is Not the Goal
Many backlink guides instruct readers to evaluate blogs by Domain Authority or similar third-party metrics.
These metrics may help with competitive research, but they should not become the reason you comment.
Google does not use Moz Domain Authority, Ahrefs Domain Rating or equivalent third-party scores as its own ranking systems.
Ask better questions:
Does the site have a genuine audience?
Is the content relevant?
Would you be proud to have your professional name visible there?
Are respected people participating?
Can your contribution help readers?
Would a visitor from this blog be useful to your business?
These questions produce better link opportunities.
How to Discover High-Quality Comment Opportunities
The best strategy is following your industry rather than hunting “comment backlinks.”
Subscribe to respected blogs.
Follow authors on LinkedIn or X.
Monitor newsletters.
Use RSS readers.
Follow Google Search results for emerging topics.
Track competitors’ mentions.
Participate in specialist communities.
When an article genuinely interests you, participate.
This produces naturally diversified commenting rather than a suspicious backlink campaign.
Comment Early When Possible
High-quality comments posted soon after publication are often more visible.
They may receive:
author responses;
reader replies;
likes;
additional discussion.
However, never sacrifice quality merely to comment first.
A thoughtful comment published tomorrow is better than a meaningless comment published five minutes after the article goes live.
Read the Entire Article Before Commenting
Nothing reveals a backlink hunter faster than a comment that clearly responds only to the title.
Read the article.
Understand:
the author’s thesis;
examples;
limitations;
arguments;
conclusion.
Then identify what you can genuinely contribute.
Useful comments commonly do one of five things:
add supporting experience;
ask an intelligent question;
introduce a relevant edge case;
clarify an overlooked consideration;
expand on one of the author’s ideas.
The “Contribution Test”
Before submitting your comment, ask:
Does this comment add information that was not already present?
If not, improve it.
“Great article” adds virtually nothing.
“Your section on content refreshing raises another question: when updating a page that already attracts backlinks, do you generally preserve the original URL and historical structure unless intent has materially changed? We have found unnecessary URL changes create more problems than the refresh solves.”
That adds a specific discussion point.
A Practical Comment Structure That Works
A high-quality comment often follows this sequence:
Acknowledge a specific point.
Add your own insight.
Explain why it matters.
Optionally ask a question.
For example:
“The distinction you made between crawlability and indexability is important because these issues are often grouped together during technical audits. One additional diagnostic I find useful is checking whether important URLs are internally linked before focusing entirely on sitemap submission. Have you seen orphan pages remain a frequent issue on large CMS migrations?”
Notice what is missing:
no advertising;
no keyword-stuffed name;
no “visit my site” request;
no artificial compliment.
The commenter sounds like a professional participant.
That is the objective.
Use Your Real Name
If the form requests a name, use your actual name or recognizable professional identity.
Good:
Biswajit Barman
Potentially acceptable when representing a brand:
Biswajit — My Advisers
Poor:
Best SEO Agency India
SEO Expert Kolkata
Cheap Backlinks Provider
Keyword-based names immediately signal SEO manipulation.
They also damage personal credibility.
Should You Put Your Website in the Website Field?
If the comment system provides a normal website field, using your legitimate homepage or professional profile is generally reasonable.
Do not repeatedly rotate landing pages trying to optimize anchor destinations.
Your identity link should behave like identification, not engineered anchor text.
For example:
Name: Biswajit Barman
Website: your legitimate website
Comment: useful contribution
This is fundamentally different from:
Name: Best SEO Services India
Website: exact commercial landing page
Comment: Great article. Visit my website.
The second pattern resembles exactly the kind of manipulative commenting that spam systems are designed to detect.
When Should You Link Inside the Comment?
Usually, you should not.
Most good comments do not require an in-body link.
Include one only when the destination materially helps the discussion.
Examples could include:
original research;
a calculator;
supporting documentation;
a relevant case study;
a public dataset;
a detailed tutorial directly answering another reader’s question.
Even then, ask whether the comment still makes sense without the link.
If it does not, the contribution may simply be disguised promotion.
Never Force an Exact-Match Anchor
A comment containing:
“Check my best SEO company in India guide”
creates an obvious commercial footprint.
If a link is genuinely necessary, use natural descriptive language.
For example:
“I documented the methodology and sample dataset here.”
The context should explain the destination.
The anchor does not need to become an SEO keyword.
Understand Why Most Comment Links Are UGC or Nofollow
Publishers face constant comment spam.
If every user-generated link automatically passed unrestricted ranking credit, blogs would become magnets for automated backlink campaigns.
Google recommends marking user-generated links such as comments and forum posts with rel="ugc". Google’s own SEO Starter Guide similarly recommends that sites accepting user-generated links automatically add nofollow or similar annotations.
Therefore, encountering UGC or nofollow links is normal.
It is not a sign that the website is bad.
In many cases, it is a sign that the publisher manages comments responsibly.
How a Dofollow Comment Link Can Be Earned Legitimately
The best path is trust.
Google’s own outbound-link documentation notes that publishers may choose to remove the UGC attribute from links posted by members or users who have consistently made high-quality contributions.
This provides an excellent model.
Become the contributor publishers trust.
Over time:
your comments are approved faster;
authors recognize your name;
you may receive contributor privileges;
your profile may receive greater visibility;
publishers may reference your website editorially;
you may be invited to contribute full content.
The followed link becomes a consequence of reputation rather than manipulation.
Become a Recognized Community Member
One valuable comment is good.
Ten valuable comments across several months can build identity.
Repeated contribution signals:
consistency;
knowledge;
professionalism;
genuine interest.
Do not repeat the same idea.
Participate when you actually have something useful to add.
Respond to Other Commenters
Many marketers focus entirely on the article author.
But real communities include readers.
Replying constructively to another reader can create relationships with:
bloggers;
business owners;
developers;
researchers;
prospective customers;
potential collaborators.
Blog commenting therefore resembles professional networking more than traditional backlink building.
Ask Intelligent Questions
Questions can generate better interactions than declarations.
Compare:
“Great SEO article.”
with:
“Have you found Search Console impressions useful for identifying content-refresh opportunities when rankings remain stable but CTR declines?”
The second comment gives the author something worth answering.
A meaningful reply can start a professional relationship.
Share Experience Without Inventing Results
Experience can strengthen comments.
But never fabricate data.
Avoid statements such as:
“This increased our traffic 800%.”
unless you can support the claim.
Instead say:
“In several site audits I have noticed…”
or:
“One issue we frequently encounter…”
or:
“In my experience with WordPress websites…”
This demonstrates practical knowledge without exaggerating.
Respect Disagreement
You do not need to agree with every article.
Thoughtful disagreement can create excellent discussion.
Use language such as:
“I interpret this slightly differently because…”
“One scenario where this may change is…”
“Would this recommendation still apply when…”
Avoid:
“You are wrong.”
“This is nonsense.”
“Clearly you don’t understand SEO.”
Professional disagreement builds credibility.
Aggressive commenting destroys it.
Never Copy and Paste Comments
Posting the same comment across multiple websites is one of the clearest spam patterns.
Every comment should be written specifically for the article.
This means commenting cannot be efficiently mass automated.
That is a feature, not a problem.
Quality backlink strategies require judgment.
Avoid AI-Generated Generic Comments
AI can help you summarize an article or brainstorm discussion points.
But publishing generic AI comments across hundreds of blogs simply creates a newer version of automated spam.
Common AI-style spam comments often sound like:
“This insightful article provides a comprehensive overview of the importance of digital marketing in today’s competitive landscape.”
It sounds polished.
It says almost nothing.
If AI assists you, rewrite the contribution based on your own knowledge and the specific article.
Do Not Use Commenting Software for Mass Backlinks
Automated link generation falls directly into dangerous territory.
Google’s spam policies identify automated programs or services that create links as examples of link spam.
Avoid tools promising:
10,000 blog comments;
instant backlinks;
high-DA comments;
automatic dofollow links;
tiered comments;
comment blasts.
These services sell quantity because genuine editorial relationships cannot be automated easily.
Avoid “Dofollow Comment Site Lists”
Large public lists of “1000 dofollow blogs” create several problems.
First, they become spam targets.
Second, many websites remove comments or change link attributes.
Third, the same domains become saturated with identical backlink-building activity.
Fourth, topical relevance is usually poor.
Fifth, many lists are years out of date.
A smaller personal list of 20 excellent industry publications is far more valuable than a spreadsheet containing 5,000 random blogs.
Should You Check Whether a Comment Link Is Dofollow?
You can inspect the HTML when conducting research.
However, do not let link attributes determine whether you participate.
If a publication is genuinely valuable, commenting may still be worthwhile regardless of attribute.
A respected industry publication with rel="ugc" may deliver far greater business value than an abandoned blog offering followed links.
How to Check a Link Attribute
Open the page in your browser.
Inspect the link.
Look for attributes such as:
rel="nofollow"
rel="ugc"
rel="sponsored"
A plain anchor without these values is often informally described as “dofollow.”
Browser SEO extensions can also identify these links.
Use these tools for understanding, not opportunity hunting.
Why Nofollow Comment Links Can Still Be Valuable
Imagine two links.
Link A:
A followed comment link on an abandoned website receiving almost no traffic.
Link B:
A rel="ugc" profile link beneath a respected marketing publication read by thousands of industry professionals.
Which is more useful?
For a serious business, Link B may provide:
visitors;
recognition;
relationships;
future editorial links;
professional opportunities.
SEO should support business outcomes.
It should not reduce every online interaction to whether PageRank theoretically passes.
Blog Commenting and Referral Traffic
Track traffic from valuable comment communities.
Use analytics to evaluate:
referral visits;
engagement;
newsletter registrations;
contact enquiries;
downloads;
conversions.
You may discover that some communities generate real customers even if every comment link is nofollow.
That makes the channel valuable.
Build a Commenting Relationship Funnel
Think of engagement as a progression:
reader → commenter → recognized contributor → relationship → collaboration → editorial mention
Most backlink hunters try to jump directly from reader to backlink.
That is why their outreach looks transactional.
Relationships compound.
Turning Comments Into Content Ideas
Comment sections reveal real questions.
If several readers repeatedly ask:
“How often should technical SEO audits be conducted?”
that may deserve a dedicated article.
Comments can therefore become audience research.
Excellent bloggers study:
questions;
objections;
misunderstandings;
follow-up requests.
These insights improve future content.
Turn Your Own Blog Into a Valuable Comment Community
The strategy works in both directions.
If you operate a blog, high-quality comments can add genuine value.
Google has long acknowledged that comments and forum discussions can be useful sources of information, while warning site owners to prevent spam from overwhelming them.
Moderate carefully.
Encourage thoughtful discussion.
Remove spam.
Reward consistent contributors.
Your comment section can become another trust signal for readers.
Should Bloggers Make All Comment Links Dofollow?
Usually, no.
Automatically allowing unrestricted followed links creates incentives for spam.
Google recommends ugc for user-generated links.
A more responsible system may use:
UGC links by default;
moderation;
reputation thresholds;
manual approval;
trusted-contributor privileges.
This approach protects both community quality and editorial control.
When a Publisher May Choose to Follow Your Link
A publisher might independently choose to provide an ordinary editorial link when:
you become a recognized contributor;
your resource directly supports the discussion;
your research is uniquely useful;
your tool solves a reader problem;
your case study adds evidence;
the author updates the article and cites your contribution.
Notice the pattern.
The link exists because the destination deserves citation.
That is how links should ideally be earned.
Create Resources Worth Linking To
If you want blog conversations to generate backlinks, give people something worth citing.
Examples include:
original research;
templates;
checklists;
calculators;
industry statistics;
benchmark reports;
case studies;
data visualizations;
free tools;
detailed tutorials;
glossaries;
frameworks.
Then, when a discussion genuinely calls for such a resource, mentioning it becomes natural.
Commenting for Personal Branding
Use the same identity consistently.
Same real name.
Same professional photograph where supported.
Same website.
Similar bio.
Over time, this creates recognition.
Readers may encounter you across:
blogs;
LinkedIn;
forums;
podcasts;
newsletters;
communities.
This consistency helps transform anonymous commenting into personal-brand development.
Commenting for Business Brands
Brands can participate too.
However, human identities often perform better.
Compare:
“SEOConsultingAgency123”
with:
“Biswajit from My Advisers”
The second is more human.
People build relationships with people.
Commenting on Competitor Blogs
You can participate in competitor or adjacent industry blogs if comments are open.
Do not promote your competing service.
Contribute professionally.
This can:
expand industry relationships;
demonstrate expertise;
introduce your brand to knowledgeable readers.
Respect the host.
Their comment section is not your advertising space.
Commenting on News and Industry Publications
Industry news creates excellent discussion opportunities.
Instead of saying:
“Thanks for the update,”
add interpretation.
For example:
“This update could have a larger impact on small ecommerce businesses than enterprise retailers because smaller sites often rely more heavily on templated product feeds. I would be interested to see whether implementation guidance changes once adoption increases.”
This shows expertise.
Blog Commenting for New Bloggers
New bloggers often struggle with visibility.
Commenting can be useful because it does not require an established audience.
A new blogger can participate immediately.
The correct goal during the first months should be:
become known;
learn from experienced publishers;
understand industry conversations;
build relationships.
Do not focus on acquiring hundreds of links.
Blog Commenting for Established Bloggers
Established publishers can use comments differently.
They may participate selectively on influential sites where:
their expertise adds value;
their research supports discussion;
their audience overlaps;
collaboration opportunities exist.
Because their brand is already established, fewer higher-quality interactions may be sufficient.
How Much Time Should You Spend Commenting?
Avoid daily quotas such as:
“Post 20 comments per day.”
Quota-based systems encourage low quality.
Instead, create a relationship-oriented routine.
For example, each week you might read several important industry articles and comment only when you have something genuinely useful to contribute.
Some weeks that may produce two comments.
Another week ten.
Natural participation varies.
A 30-Minute Blog Commenting Workflow
A practical workflow might look like this:
Spend ten minutes reviewing your preferred industry sources.
Spend ten minutes reading one or two genuinely relevant articles.
Spend ten minutes writing and revising one thoughtful contribution.
One excellent comment is better than twenty automated ones.
How Long Should a Blog Comment Be?
There is no ideal word count.
Some useful comments are 40 words.
Others are 300.
The correct length depends on the idea.
Avoid extremely long comments that attempt to turn another person’s website into your publishing platform.
If your response becomes an entire article, consider writing the full article on your own site and contributing only the essential insight in the comment.
How to Avoid Looking Promotional
Remove phrases such as:
“Check my website.”
“Visit my blog.”
“Buy my service.”
“I offer this service.”
“Click here.”
“Contact me.”
Unless the article explicitly requests recommendations, these phrases make comments look promotional.
Let your name or profile identify you.
Your expertise should create curiosity.
Comment Moderation Delays Are Normal
High-quality blogs often manually review comments.
Do not resubmit repeatedly.
Do not email the publisher asking why your backlink was not approved.
Wait.
Moderation is evidence that the publisher protects quality.
What If the Publisher Removes Your Link?
Accept it.
The publisher owns the website.
If the comment remains useful without the link, the contribution still builds visibility.
Complaining about link removal reveals that the backlink was probably the real motivation.
What If the Publisher Changes Your Link to Nofollow or UGC?
Again, accept it.
Google recommends such attributes for user-generated links.
Do not ask editors to “make my link dofollow for SEO.”
That request can immediately damage credibility.
Never Pay for Dofollow Blog Comments
If someone offers:
“$20 for permanent dofollow comment”
be cautious.
Google considers buying or selling links for ranking purposes a form of link spam unless paid links are appropriately qualified.
Comment sections are not legitimate paid-link marketplaces.
Avoid Link Exchanges Through Comments
Do not leave comments like:
“I linked to you; please link back.”
Google’s spam policies explicitly identify excessive reciprocal linking created for ranking purposes as problematic.
Genuine relationships can naturally produce mutual references.
Do not make links conditional.
Blog Commenting vs Guest Posting
Blog comments are discussion contributions.
Guest posts are full editorial contributions.
If your relationship with a publisher develops, guest publishing may become a natural next step.
A comment saying:
“I have been testing this approach across several WordPress sites and observed an interesting pattern…”
may start a discussion.
Months later, an editor might invite you to document the methodology.
That guest article can create genuine audience value and editorial recognition.
Blog Commenting vs Digital PR
Digital PR targets journalists and publishers with newsworthy stories, research and expert commentary.
Blog commenting is usually slower and relationship-oriented.
The strategies complement each other.
A journalist may recognize your name from industry conversations before receiving your future research pitch.
Familiarity increases trust.
Blog Commenting vs Forum Participation
Forums usually support deeper ongoing conversations.
Blog comments are usually tied to a specific article.
Both should follow the same principle:
participate because you have something useful to contribute.
Google recommends ugc for both comment and forum links.
Blog Commenting vs Social Media Comments
Social platforms can produce faster visibility.
Blog comments often have longer shelf life because they remain attached to evergreen articles.
A useful comment beneath an article ranking in search may continue receiving readers years later.
That makes high-quality evergreen discussions particularly interesting.
Build a Personal Blog Commenting Database
Instead of downloading public “dofollow lists,” maintain your own research database.
Record:
publication;
topic;
author;
article URL;
date commented;
discussion topic;
response;
relationship notes;
referral traffic;
future opportunity.
This turns commenting into relationship management.
Do not obsess over link attributes.
Track business value.
Prioritize Relationships Over Metrics
Suppose one blog has DR 85 but no interaction.
Another has DR 55 and its editor regularly responds to you.
The second relationship may become far more useful.
Human connections can generate opportunities no backlink metric predicts.
Use Commenting to Support Topical Authority
Participating regularly within your niche reinforces your professional positioning among humans.
If you publish about:
SEO;
AI;
web development;
analytics;
automation;
digital marketing,
then commenting on these subjects supports a coherent public identity.
Avoid jumping between unrelated niches purely because a followed link is available.
Can Blog Comments Improve E-E-A-T?
Do not think of E-E-A-T as a score earned through backlinks.
Google’s quality concepts involve signals associated with experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trust.
Thoughtful public participation may help human audiences recognize expertise, but leaving comments does not create a guaranteed E-E-A-T ranking boost.
Use comments to demonstrate real knowledge, not to manufacture a theoretical score.
Measure the Right Outcomes
Useful metrics include:
publisher replies;
repeat recognition;
referral traffic;
conversations;
newsletter signups;
collaboration invitations;
earned mentions;
editorial backlinks;
business enquiries.
Counting raw comment backlinks is a weak metric.
One relationship leading to a legitimate publication mention may outweigh hundreds of comment URLs.
Signs Your Blog Commenting Strategy Is Becoming Spammy
Audit yourself regularly.
Danger signs include:
commenting mainly on websites because they provide followed links;
using keyword-rich names;
copying similar comments;
posting without reading articles;
automating submissions;
commenting across unrelated industries;
placing links in every comment;
using commercial anchor text;
paying for comments;
measuring only backlink quantity.
If several of these describe your campaign, change direction.
A White-Hat Blog Commenting Framework
Use this sequence:
Discover → Read → Understand → Contribute → Engage → Build Trust → Develop Relationship → Earn Opportunity
Do not reverse it into:
Find dofollow → Insert backlink → Leave
The first model produces reputation.
The second produces footprints.
Example of a Spam Comment
“Great post! I really liked your article about SEO. SEO is very important for every business. Visit my website for the best SEO services in India.”
Problems:
generic;
self-promotional;
keyword-driven;
no evidence the article was read;
commercial link motive;
adds no new information.
Example of a High-Quality Comment
“Your point about internal linking being part of the publishing workflow rather than a later SEO task is especially useful. One issue I would add is reverse linking: after publishing a new article, older authoritative pages should also be reviewed for opportunities to link forward to the new resource. Otherwise the new page may remain structurally weak even if it links extensively to older content.”
This comment:
references a specific argument;
adds a useful concept;
demonstrates experience;
does not advertise;
invites discussion.
That is what good commenting looks like.
Example of a Comment With a Legitimate Supporting Link
Suppose an article discusses Core Web Vitals and asks readers for real-world examples.
A useful contribution might say:
“We encountered an interesting LCP issue where the apparent hero image was not the real bottleneck; delayed stylesheet processing was postponing when the browser could render it. I documented the waterfall screenshots and remediation steps in a case study here for anyone diagnosing a similar pattern.”
The link has a reason to exist.
It provides supporting evidence.
If the comment works only because the backlink exists, it is weaker.
Create a Commenting Code of Conduct for Yourself
Before every submission, confirm:
I read the article.
My comment addresses the article.
I added something new.
I used my real identity.
I did not stuff keywords.
I did not force a backlink.
Any link is directly relevant.
I would still post this without SEO benefit.
I would be comfortable showing this comment publicly as part of my professional reputation.
If all are true, you are probably operating responsibly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are blog comments good for SEO?
They can support SEO indirectly through discovery, referral traffic, relationships and future editorial mentions. Treating comments mainly as ranking-link placements is much less defensible.
Are dofollow blog comments still available?
Some websites may provide ordinary followed links, while many use ugc or nofollow. Google recommends ugc for user-generated links such as comments.
How can I find dofollow blog commenting sites?
Do not build your strategy around public dofollow lists. Identify respected publications within your niche and participate where your expertise adds value.
Is commenting with my website URL spam?
Not necessarily. Using a legitimate website field to identify yourself can be reasonable. Spam begins when links, anchor text or comments are manipulated primarily to influence rankings.
Should I use keywords as my commenter name?
No. Use your real name or professional identity.
Should I place my homepage or article URL?
If the form provides a website/profile field, your main professional website is usually appropriate. In-body links should be included only when genuinely relevant.
Are nofollow comments useless?
No. They can generate traffic, relationships, discovery, visibility and future opportunities. Google also treats nofollow, ugc and sponsored as hints rather than the simplistic binary model used in older SEO discussions.
Can mass blog commenting hurt SEO?
Automated or manipulative comment link creation can fall under Google’s link spam and user-generated spam policies.
How many blog comments should I create per day?
Do not use a backlink quota. Comment when you have something genuinely useful to contribute.
Can AI write blog comments for me?
AI may assist research or ideation, but publishing generic machine-generated comments at scale recreates the same spam problem as older automation.
How long should a blog comment be?
As long as necessary to contribute meaningfully. There is no ideal word count.
Can blog commenting generate customers?
Yes. Relevant publications can send qualified referral traffic, especially when your contribution demonstrates expertise.
Is blog commenting better than guest posting?
They serve different purposes. Commenting builds participation and relationships. Guest posting allows deeper editorial contribution.
Should bloggers allow dofollow links in comments?
Automatically allowing unrestricted followed links can attract spam. Google recommends ugc for user-generated links. Publishers can make their own editorial decisions for trusted contributors.
Can I ask a blogger to change my link from nofollow to dofollow?
Usually you should not. Respect the publisher’s link policy.
What is the safest long-term strategy?
Become a recognizable, useful participant in your niche and create resources people genuinely want to cite.
A Sustainable 90-Day Blog Commenting Strategy
During the first month, identify a small group of respected publications in your niche. Read them regularly. Do not rush to comment everywhere. Learn who writes the articles, what subjects generate discussion and what contribution quality is expected.
During the second month, begin participating selectively. Focus on thoughtful contributions. Respond to authors and other commenters. Avoid promotional links unless a specific resource genuinely improves the conversation.
During the third month, deepen the strongest relationships. Connect with authors professionally where appropriate. Share their genuinely useful work. Consider collaborative opportunities such as interviews, expert contributions, research, guest articles or webinars.
At the end of 90 days, evaluate not merely how many backlinks appeared but whether you gained:
relationships;
recognition;
referral visitors;
professional conversations;
content ideas;
collaboration opportunities;
editorial mentions.
That is a healthier definition of success.
Final Takeaway
Blog commenting is not dead.
Spam blog commenting should be.
The sustainable opportunity is not discovering thousands of websites where comment links happen to be followed.
The opportunity is becoming a useful participant in communities that matter to your audience.
Read carefully.
Contribute knowledge.
Use your real identity.
Avoid keyword-rich anchors.
Do not automate.
Do not pay for comment links.
Respect nofollow and ugc.
Create resources worth citing.
Build genuine relationships.
Over time, the strongest backlinks may not come from the comment itself.
They may come from the blogger who later cites your research, invites you to contribute an article, interviews you, recommends your resource or introduces your work to an entirely new audience.
That is the difference between placing backlinks and earning authority.
And for bloggers building a sustainable search presence, authority is the far more valuable goal.
Discover more from My Advisers
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.